💭 Motion Statistics
Round 1

That we prefer police chiefs to be elected rather than appointed (Police Chiefs)

18%
9%
2 Aff wins 1 Neg win
balance inconclusive
14%
27%
3 Aff vetoes 6 Neg vetoes
balance inconclusive

That we should prohibit the elderly from voting or running for public office (Mitch McConnell)

9%
0 Aff wins 1 Neg win
balance inconclusive
23%
14%
5 Aff vetoes 3 Neg vetoes
balance inconclusive

That we support the politics of class warfare (Class Warfare)

View Info Slide
18%
45%
2 Aff wins 5 Neg wins
balance inconclusive
14%
9%
3 Aff vetoes 2 Neg vetoes
balance inconclusive
Round 2

That social media platforms should be held legally liable for hosted content that passes a certain threshold of 'clout' (e.g. pageviews). (Elon)

17%
8%
2 Aff wins 1 Neg win
balance inconclusive
17%
29%
4 Aff vetoes 7 Neg vetoes
imbalanced at 50% level

That we prefer a world where full digital anonymity is and was the norm (Anonymity)

17%
17%
2 Aff wins 2 Neg wins
balance inconclusive
21%
8%
5 Aff vetoes 2 Neg vetoes
balance inconclusive

That we regret the commercialisation of fan fiction (Fan-Fic)

8%
33%
1 Aff win 4 Neg wins
balance inconclusive
13%
13%
3 Aff vetoes 3 Neg vetoes
balance inconclusive
Round 3

That it is in China's interest to allow for "haircuts" as opposed to maturity extensions in Africa's debt-restructuring negotiations. (Mullets, thoughts?)

View Info Slide
17%
8%
2 Aff wins 1 Neg win
balance inconclusive
25%
6 Aff vetoes 1 Neg veto
balance inconclusive

That we prefer a world where worker co-operatives were the norm, as opposed to traditional firms. (Going co-op)

View Info Slide
33%
25%
4 Aff wins 3 Neg wins
balance inconclusive
8%
21%
2 Aff vetoes 5 Neg vetoes
balance inconclusive

That central banks should implement the Maradona Theory during times of economic crisis. (Madonna)

View Info Slide
8%
8%
1 Aff win 1 Neg win
balance inconclusive
17%
25%
4 Aff vetoes 6 Neg vetoes
probably balanced
Round 4

That, as the parent of minority children, we would raise our children to regard negative life outcomes as primarily a product of personal failure rather than resulting from systemic discrimination. (Parental Messaging)

10%
1 Aff win 0 Neg wins
balance inconclusive
20%
15%
4 Aff vetoes 3 Neg vetoes
balance inconclusive

That we oppose the use of false consciousness arguments by progressive social movements. (False Consciousness)

View Info Slide
40%
4 Aff wins 0 Neg wins
balance inconclusive
15%
25%
3 Aff vetoes 5 Neg vetoes
balance inconclusive

That, as a philanthropsist, we would heavily prioritise donating to research and development projects (e.g. AI safety development, climate change research) over humanitarian projects (e.g. Red Cross, UNICEF). (EA)

50%
0 Aff wins 5 Neg wins
balance inconclusive
15%
10%
3 Aff vetoes 2 Neg vetoes
balance inconclusive
Round 5

That we prefer education systems to adopt the knowledge approach over the talent approach. (Empowering Teachers)

View Info Slide
30%
3 Aff wins 0 Neg wins
balance inconclusive
15%
25%
3 Aff vetoes 5 Neg vetoes
balance inconclusive

That we prefer a world where parents are honest with their children about their (i.e. parents') imperfections and insecurities (Parental Honesty)

30%
30%
3 Aff wins 3 Neg wins
balance inconclusive
15%
0 Aff vetoes 3 Neg vetoes
balance inconclusive
Semifinals

That, as Benny Gantz, we would leave the war time cabinet and push for an election. (Israel)

View Info Slide
50%
0 Aff wins 1 Neg win
balance inconclusive
25%
25%
1 Aff veto 1 Neg veto
balance inconclusive

That assuming feasibility, we would destroy all nuclear weapons and permanently remove all knowledge of how to build and maintain nuclear weaponry (Nukes go boom)

50%
0 Aff wins 1 Neg win
balance inconclusive
25%
0 Aff vetoes 1 Neg veto
balance inconclusive
Grand Final

That it is in the interests of the Catholic Church to elect an African Pope to succeed Pope Francis. (African Pope)

100%
1 Aff win 0 Neg wins
balance inconclusive
No teams vetoed this motion